Rheinischer Sauerbraten (Sour Roast)

A Tangy-Sweet Taste of German Tradition

Sauerbraten with Potato Dumplings and Red Cabbage

Go to the recipe

If there’s one dish that embodies the soul of Germany’s Rhineland cuisine, it’s Rheinischer Sauerbraten. This classic German pot roast is a culinary masterpiece that harmoniously blends tangy, sweet, and savory flavors into a dish that has stood the test of time.

A Dish with Deep Roots

The origins of Sauerbraten trace back to medieval Germany, where marinating meat in vinegar and spices was a practical way to preserve it before refrigeration. Over the centuries, this technique evolved into a beloved recipe, with regional variations adding unique twists. Legend attributes the dish’s invention to Charlemagne (742–814 AD), who purportedly suggested preserving roasted meat in a vinegar-based marinade. However, this claim is more mythical than historical. In the Rhineland, the addition of raisins and gingersnaps sets their version apart, creating a delightful balance of tartness and sweetness.

Originally, Sauerbraten was often made with horse meat because its natural slight sweetness complements the sour marinade. However, modern versions almost exclusively use beef, reflecting changes in culinary preferences.

The Magic of Marinade

Sauerbraten Marinade

At the heart of Rheinischer Sauerbraten is its marinade. Beef is soaked for several days in a mixture of vinegar, red wine, onions, and aromatic spices like cloves, bay leaves, and juniper berries. This process not only tenderizes the meat but also infuses it with rich, tangy flavors.

Once marinated, the meat is slow-cooked until fork-tender, and the marinade is transformed into a luscious sauce. Gingersnaps and raisins are added to the sauce, giving it a velvety texture and a hint of sweetness that balances the dish’s bold acidity.

A Feast for the Senses

Traditionally, Rheinischer Sauerbraten is served with potato dumplings, red cabbage, or spaetzle, making it a comforting and hearty meal. The interplay of flavors—tart, sweet, and savory—reflects the Rhineland’s culinary identity, where contrasts create harmony.

A Dish Worth Celebrating

Whether exploring German cuisine for the first time or revisiting an old favorite, Rheinischer Sauerbraten is a must-try dish. Its rich history and bold flavors make it more than just a meal—it’s a taste of tradition and a reminder of the ingenuity of cooks from centuries past.

Next time you’re in the mood for something truly special, try Rheinischer Sauerbraten. It’s a dish that tells a story, one delicious bite at a time

Rheinischer Sauerbraten (Sour Roast)

Ingredients

For the marinade: 

• 2 large Yellow Onions, chopped

•  2 large Carrots, chopped

•  1 large Leek, chopped

• 1 cup chopped Celeriac (Celery Root), approx. 1/4 inch cubes

•  1/2 cup Raisins (preferably golden raisins)

•  1 bottle Dry Red Wine (note 2)

•  2 cups Red Wine Vinegar

•  2 sprigs Thyme

•  2 sprigs Rosemary

•  2-3 Bay Leaves

•  1 tsp (approx. 12 pieces) Juniper Berries

•  1/2 tsp (approx. 8 pieces) Whole Cloves

• 1/2 tsp Allspice

•  1 tsp whole Black Peppercorns, cracked

•  1 tbsp teaspoons Kosher Salt

•  1 tbsp Brown Sugar (white sugar is OK)

For the roast:

• 3 pounds beef roast (chuck or rump) (note 1)

•  2 tbsp Tallow or Avocado Oil (or any oil with a high smoke point)

•  10 Gingersnap Cookies, crushed

• Salt and Pepper to taste

  
  

The Process

1. In a large pot, combine all of the marinade ingredients and boil for 10 minutes at medium-high heat. Let the marinade cool completely.

2. Add the beef to the marinade and cover. The meat must be completely covered! (note 3)

3. Marinate the beef for 5 - 10 days. As longer as better, but not longer than two weeks. Turn the meat once in a while.

4. Remove roast from the marinade and pat dry with paper towels. Set the marinade aside.

5. Add tallow or oil to a dutch oven and heat to high heat. Wait until the tallow or oil is very hot and add the meet to the dutch oven. Brown the meat on all sides approx. 2-3 minutes per side. (note 4)

6. Add the marinade to the dutch oven and bring it to a boil. Cover the pot and reduce heat to simmer.

7. Simmer for 2 1/2 - 3 hours, until meat is tender.

   

   Simmer the Sauerbraten

8. Remove meat from the cooking liquids and set it aside on a cutting board. Cover it with foil and let it rest for 10 minutes.

9. In the meantime, strain the marinade, discarding the solids and reserving the liquid. Make sure you press all the good liquids out of the strainer. Return the liquid to the dutch oven. 

10. Add the crushed gingersnap cookies to the liquid in the dutch oven. Cook and stir over medium-low heat for 10 minutes until thickened into a nice gravy. Taste and add salt and pepper to taste.

11. Slice the sauerbraten into thin slices and retrun them to the pot to heat up in the sauce.

12. Serve the sauerbraten together with potato dumplings or spaetzle and red cabbage. (note 5)

Notes:

1. A Rump Roast is higher and rounder than a Chuck Roast and looks nicer when sliced. However, it can be a little bit dryer. This is undoubtedly a matter of taste. Any roast meat would do it, as marinating it for several days will tenderize even the toughest cuts.

2. Yes! We use the entire bottle! Any dry red wine will do. Do not use sweet wine, as it would bring the marinade out of balance. Never use any cheap wine. Use a wine you would like to drink as well.

3. You can cover it in a pot. However, you must ensure that the entire meat piece is submerged in the liquid. This will ensure that it is preserved. My favorite method is using a vacuum sealer and a large plastic bag. That will always guarantee that the meat is not uncovered.

4. Ensure all sides, even the thin ends, are browned well. This will start the Maillard reaction, which results in better flavors.

5. You can certainly make potato dumplings from scratch. I will upload a recipe soon, although it is a lot of work. As a beginner, you can buy potato dumplings in a package. I find them almost as good as homemade.

   
   

Wine Pairing

Villa Wolf Pinot Noir 2019 or similar Pinot Noir

Why:

The German Pinot Noir, known in Germany as Spätburgunder, is a nice match for a Sauerbraten. You want a medium-bodied wine. Its fruitiness, with hints of cherry, strawberry, and pomegranate, complements the sauce's sour taste. Its spices, such as vanilla, allspice, and nutmeg, will add complexity.

However, Sauerbraten is forgiving. Its complex flavors allow for a range of wine choices, from our German Pino Noir over a medium-bodied Cabernet Sauvignon to a Beaujolais is acceptable. Just don’t go too dry.

One more interesting recommendation from Dr. Vinny at Wine Spectator is to skip red wines altogether and sip a German Spätlese or an off-dry Riesling from California together with the German roast.

There is flexibility. Try it out, and let me know what works for you.

Music Pairing

Rheinlieder Medley - A collection of songs of the Rheinland

Listen to music

Why:

The River Rhine area is known for a happy culture, celbrating the Carnival season especially in Köln (Cologne) and Düsseldorf and for its numerous wine festivals. Therefore music about this area tells stories of happiness, dancing and drinking wine. On many of the wine festivals, you can order a Sauerbraten as a perfect meal, celebrating the happiness.